16 Best shaving creams for sensitive skin (2023)

You know the struggle of getting a close shave, especially if you have sensitive skin. You might end up with skin that is more irritated, red, and full of bumps or cuts than before you shaved your beard. This can be incredibly frustrating, but thankfully it doesn’t have to be this way. By simply switching the shaving products you use, you can find a regimen that finally allows you to enjoy shaving.

Let’s focus on shaving creams. Shaving creams are designed to help you get a close shave with less irritation. With the right combination of ingredients, shaving cream can help the razor glide across your skin and lift the hair to make it easier to shave. Selecting a shaving cream with moisturizing ingredients will most likely make your skin feel super soft and smooth after shaving.

Now is the time to start using a shaving cream, if you are not already doing so. Or if you have been disappointed by shaving creams in the past, don’t worry! There are a variety of new options available that you can take advantage of. Testing out a few different products will help you find the best fit for your skin.

Shopping for Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin

Shaving cream can be a really helpful addition to your shaving routine, but what if you have sensitive skin? What if you have tried shaving creams in the past, only to have them irritate your skin? Have no fear as there are plenty of shaving creams that are formulated with sensitive skin in mind. These products can help hydrate your skin, as well as provide protection from your razor to help prevent bumps, nicks, cuts, redness, and more.

Although most shaving products you may see are made for various types of skin, you will be surprised by the wide variety of sensitive skin options that are available. You just need to know where to look and which brands to check for.

From products that are made with natural and organic ingredients to those that are vegan and cruelty-free, and those that are produced by well-known brands that you might already support, there is a multitude of shaving creams for sensitive skin that are worth your attention. The key is figuring out which one is the best one for you!

Want to Start Your Search for the Right Shaving Cream?

If you’re ready to start shopping for shaving products that are ideal for men with sensitive skin, keep reading to access a list of 16 best shaving creams for sensitive skin. Make sure to read through the brief descriptions to get an idea of each product offers, then consider giving one or more of them a try to find out what works for you.

1. Blu Atlas Shave Cream

First on the list of the best shaving creams for sensitive skin is the Shave Cream from Blu Atlas. This brand offers several products for the face, hair, and body, and their shaving cream should definitely be on your radar as a great option for sensitive skin.

The shaving cream has a formulation that is exactly what you need to help soothe your skin while you shave. Ingredients include coco-caprylate, which helps soothe and soften skin, and tocopherol acetate, which is an antioxidant that can keep your skin looking amazing. This product is vegan and does not contain artificial fragrances, which some people with sensitive skin might find irritating.

To make the most of this shaving cream, all you have to do is apply a thin layer and then shave like you normally would. You may notice that your skin becomes less inflamed, and you might also notice that you don’t end up with all of the cuts that could happen when you shave your delicate skin.

2. Vanicream Shave Cream

Another good product to consider is the Shave Cream from Vanicream, which is specifically made for sensitive skin. If you have found that other shaving creams contain ingredients that irritate your face, this might be the right solution for you.

This is non-lathering shaving cream and it does not contain any alcohol, gluten, essential oils, dyes, fragrances, lanolin, parabens, botanical extracts, or formaldehyde. So, you can immediately see that they left out a lot of ingredients that you might want to stay away from.

This dermatologist-tested shaving cream can be used to get a close shave. It is designed for both men and women and can be worth trying if you want to avoid cuts and razor burn. Simply wet your skin, use a thin layer of this shaving cream, shave carefully, and rinse to reveal skin that feels softer and smoother.

3. Neutrogena Men Sensitive Skin Shave Cream

Are you a fan of the brand Neutrogena? If you answered yes, you might be wondering if they offer a shaving cream that you can use on your sensitive skin. Well, you can try their Sensitive Skin Shave Cream that is made for men.

The ingredients in this formulation can be helpful if your skin tends to get irritated when you shave, as they help soothe your skin and calm it so you can hopefully avoid annoying irritation. Plus, this is a product that does not contain any dyes, and it is non-comedogenic so it won’t clog your pores. It might be exactly what you need if you tend to get ingrown hairs and embarrassing bumps from shaving.

Like the items above, you only need to apply a thin layer of this shaving cream to get great results. Shave carefully, and you should notice that you achieved a close shave with smooth results, which you will be really happy with.

4. Andalou Naturals Men Smooth Glide Shave Cream

Are you looking for a shaving cream that is not only a good choice for those with sensitive skin but is also vegan, cruelty free, and gluten free? In that case, you should definitely consider checking out the Smooth Glide Shave Cream from Andalou Naturals.

This brand offers a variety of products for the face, body, and hair, and has options for both men and women. This particular product is made for men and it contains natural and certified organic ingredients. Plus, it is designed to help soothe your skin so you can avoid irritation and cuts while shaving.

This shaving cream is made for all skin types, but because it is gentle and contains ingredients like hemp stem cells, organic aloe vera, and organic hemp seed oil, it helps sensitive skin feel amazing after using it. Also, because this is semi-transparent and you only need to apply a thin layer to your skin, you might find it easier to shave and will give yourself the perfect look.

5. Barbasol Sensitive Skin Thick & Rich Shaving Cream

You are probably already pretty familiar with the Barbasol brand. If you have sensitive skin, it is worth checking out their Sensitive Skin Thick & Rich Shaving Cream, even if you have never used a product from this company before. It features ingredients like papaya, thyme, willow bark, and aloe to help your sensitive skin feel great when you need to get a close shave. After using this product, your skin will feel moisturized, soft, and smooth.

This is a great choice if you prefer using a shaving cream that produces a thick lather. It can help your razor easily glide against your skin, while also helping to protect your sensitive skin from cuts and irritation. Just keep in mind that this shave cream does have a light fragrance, so if you need to stick with fragrance-free skin care products, it might not be right for you.

6. Proraso Shaving Cream Tube: Sensitive Skin

When you start your search for top quality shaving creams, you may end up coming across the brand Proraso. And if you have sensitive skin, it is certainly worth taking the time to check out what their Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin has to offer.

This skin care product has a lot of attractive features. If you prefer products that contain natural ingredients and ingredients that are not derived from animals, this one has both. And if you want a shaving cream that will be cruelty free, as well as free of parabens, artificial colors, silicones, SLS, mineral oils, and phthalates, this one won’t disappoint.

A couple of the ingredients in this shaving cream are green tea and oatmeal. These can be a good choice for those who have sensitive skin and prefer to use a product that can provide protection against irritation, redness, and razor burn. Also, the lather that this shaving cream produces is rich, and the light scent can also make shaving an even more enjoyable experience.

7. Gillette 2 in 1 ProGlide Shave Gel

Some men prefer using a shaving cream that has a gel consistency, and if you are one of those men, it is worth looking at the Gillette 2 in 1 ProGlide Shave Gel to see what it has to offer. This product is formulated to help your sensitive skin feel nice and smooth after a shave. But because it is a 2-in-1 formula, you also get to feel the effects of a refreshing aftershave. Isn’t that neat?

In other words, you can use this one product to achieve a smoother shave with less irritation and to enjoy a cooling sensation on your skin. Also since it is made for those with sensitive skin, it might be the ideal solution if you have tried other shaving creams, but have been disappointed with the way they made your skin feel.

Just keep in mind that this shaving cream contains fragrance, so as mentioned above, if that is an ingredient you want to avoid, it might not be the perfect choice.

8. Pacific Shaving Co. Natural Shaving Cream

Yet another great option in the world of shaving creams for sensitive skin is the Pacific Shaving Co. Natural Shaving Cream. This is also another fantastic choice if you prefer using skin care products that boast natural ingredients and those that are derived from plants.

Overall, this formula is designed to help your skin feel less irritated, softer, and smoother. It might be just what you have been searching for if you want a shave cream that could help reduce unsightly bumps and redness while helping your sensitive skin feel so much better.

This is a vegan and cruelty free product, and it contains certified organic ingredients too. Simply looking through the ingredients list you will see the many easy-to-recognize ingredients in this product. It does not contain any parabens, and if you are the type of person who wants to avoid synthetic fragrances, you will be happy to know that there aren’t any in this shaving cream.

9. The Art of Shaving Unscented Shaving Cream

The Unscented Shaving Cream from The Art of Shaving should also be on your radar for those with sensitive skin. It does not contain any fragrance, alcohol, or synthetic dyes, and it can hydrate your hair and skin for an easier and smoother shave. It has been clinically tested for sensitive skin, as well as dermatologically tested.

With ingredients like coconut acid and glycerin, this shaving cream produces a lather that is thick to help protect your sensitive skin while you are shaving. If you want to take your shaving routine to the next level and make it a more enjoyable experience with less skin irritation, this product might be a good place to start.

10. Face Skin Care Ultimate Comfort Shave Cream

The Ultimate Comfort Shave Cream from Face Skin Care is made for men and women who have sensitive skin and prefer skin care products that are fragrance free. It comes in a jar with a wide mouth for your convenience, so it can be a good alternative to products that come in tubes if you don’t like them. It is also free of parabens and not tested on animals, which is something that a lot of consumers these days look for in the products that they purchase.

The ingredients in this unscented formulation can help you get a fantastic shave while helping you avoid irritation. But what really makes this shaving cream stand out from others on the market is the fact that it contains Lidocaine as an active ingredient to help diminish the amount of pain you can experience from shaving.

11. Viking Revolution Shaving Cream Sensitive Skin - Unscented

Viking Revolution offers a Shaving Cream that is made for sensitive skin. It is unscented and the lather that this shaving cream produces can help you feel like you are truly pampering yourself while you are shaving.

If you are the type of man that prefers shaving with a bowl and a brush, this shaving cream might be just what you are looking for. It can help you get smoother results with the help of organic ingredients, and you might be surprised by the small amount that you need to use each time in order to get great results.

12. Paula’s Choice PC4MEN Shave

The PC4MEN Shave from Paula’s Choice can be another good option to consider when searching for a shaving cream that can calm your skin. If you have sensitive skin that reacts to fragrances or menthol, be rest assured that neither of these are found in this product. The shaving product produces a rich cream and helps reduce redness while making shaving less irritating.

This is a shaving cream that can soothe your skin while helping you get a close shave that will make you look and feel amazing. Plus, it rinses away easily, which is definitely a nice feature when you have skin that is sensitive.

Overall, this product is worth trying, as you might notice that your skin feels softer and smoother. You might also note that your skin doesn’t develop bumps like it did with other shaving creams.

13. Van Der Hagen Whipped Shave Créme

Next up on this list is the Whipped Shave Crème from Van Der Hagen. Its lightweight and airy features can help protect your skin while you shave. The result is skin that is smoother, moisturized, and not covered in nicks or razor burn. What’s also nice about this shaving cream is that it comes in a container that is easy to open, even one-handed, because it has a flip-top design.

The moisturizing ingredients in this product can soften your sensitive skin instead of other shaving creams that have irritated your skin or caused your skin to feel dry in the past. It definitely is worth checking out this option to see how it works for you.

14. Schick Edge Ultra Sensitive Shave Gel

The Schick Edge Ultra Sensitive Shave Gel can be a solid choice if you have skin that gets irritated easily. It is dermatologist tested and has many likable product features. First off, it protects your skin so it will not get irritated and it can also help protect against cuts and nicks. Plus, the ingredients in this product include oatmeal and allantoin.

In addition, this shaving cream can help when it comes to moisturizing your sensitive skin. You might notice while using it, that your razor is able to glide across your skin much smoother than with other shaving creams. You don’t need to worry about this product containing any added dyes either, so if your skin is sensitive to those types of ingredients, this should be on your radar.

15. Truefitt & Hill Ultimate Comfort Shaving Cream Bowl

The Ultimate Comfort Shaving Cream Bowl from Truefitt & Hill is conveniently packaged, and it is formulated for sensitive skin. You can use this shaving cream to get a close shave, and the ingredients can also help your skin look and feel much better. Because this product is unscented, you do not need to worry about any added fragrances that might be irritating to the skin.

Ingredients include glycerin and lavender essential oil, which work to help moisturize and heal your skin. Also, this shaving cream produces a lather that is rich and thick to help you get a more comfortable shave. Customer reviews of this shaving cream are very positive as well, so it is definitely worth your consideration if you are looking for something new for your shaving routine.

16. The Henna Guys Shaving Butter

Last, but certainly not least, is the Shaving Butter from The Henna Guys. This is yet another shaving cream for men that can help soothe sensitive skin, and it has a lot of attractive features, such as being vegan and cruelty free, as well as gluten free. It does not contain any SLS and it is available in multiple fragrance options, including unscented. So, if you are sensitive to fragrances, you can go with the unscented option or if your skin doesn’t react to fragrance, you can select the scent that you like best.

This shaving cream can help you enjoy an easier and smoother shave with less irritation. If you are really tired of experiencing problems like razor burn, this product might be the perfect solution. It contains various ingredients that are natural and organic, such as jojoba oil, papaya, pineapple, and organic shea butter, along with aloe juice and essential oils.

Overall, this product works gently to moisturize, soothe, and exfoliate, as well as soften your skin. Check out the ingredients list to see what makes this shaving cream a worthwhile choice.

What Should You Consider While Shopping for Shaving Cream?

Shopping for the right shaving cream might seem pretty simple and straightforward, especially since there are so many products that you can choose from. But when you have sensitive skin, paying close attention to a shaving cream’s details and ingredients is wise. By doing so, you will take steps to avoid unwanted ingredients that make your skin’s condition worse rather than better.

What are some of the things you should look for when shopping for a shaving cream for men with sensitive skin? One of the first things you can do is consider whether you want to go with a product from a brand that uses natural ingredients or if you want to buy from a conventional brand that you might already be familiar with. For instance, some people prefer to go with shaving creams that contain natural ingredients if they have sensitive skin and want to start using gentler products on their face.

Speaking of ingredients, some consumers also prefer going with skin care products that do not contain ingredients like phthalates, parabens, and various synthetic ingredients. There are plenty of items on the market today that give you the opportunity to purchase from brands that avoid those types of ingredients if that is what you want.

Also, when it comes to sensitive skin, you might find that using products that are scented is not the best idea, especially artificial fragrances. It might be better to stick with products that use essential oils to provide a more natural fragrance. However, there is the chance that even ingredients like essential oils will be bothersome too. In that case, it is best to stick with unscented and fragrance free shaving creams. Again, there are plenty of options that you can choose from based on your skin’s needs, so don’t worry about being limited.

Finally, many shaving creams clearly state that they are formulated specifically for sensitive skin. Even if a product doesn’t have that statement on its label, it doesn’t necessarily mean that it isn’t right for you.

As mentioned above, you can look through the ingredients and learn about how a product works on the skin to reduce irritation or help you get a closer shave. In other words, keeping all of a product’s features in mind is key.