Recently the Salt Lake City Council passed a 180-day prohibition on data center development. The council is rightly concerned about water quality and heavy metals, wildlife impacts, electricity rate hikes, and air, noise and light pollution.
I spoke in support of the prohibition for another reason. This April, the Utah Legislature quietly stripped Utahns’ and local governments’ access to the courts if and when data centers actually do harm the community. These two laws, HB591 and HB222, provide broad immunity from nuisance suits and climate suits.
HB591, passed by Rep. Colin Jack, a utility executive from southern Utah, gutted Utah’s public nuisance laws: the types of legal remedies that have been used to take on Big Tobacco and Big Pharma. These laws could have been used by residents or cities to sue data centers that became bad neighbors, plaguing communities with pollution from backup diesel generators or draining the water table. Now that authority rests solely with Attorney General Derek Brown, a former lobbyist for Facebook and other tech interests who joined Rep. Jack on the stand to promote the bill.
HB222, sponsored by Rep. Carl Albrecht, another utility executive from central Utah, immunizes corporations from suits for harms caused by fossil fuel combustion. With data center developers pushing for energy as quickly as possible and frequently turning to “temporary” inefficient diesel or methane gas to power their facilities, communities across the state have lost the guardrails they used to have to take on high impact polluting facilities in their neighborhood.
Cities and counties around the state should take notice. The 180 day prohibition that Salt Lake City adopted is a good start. Officials must follow suit and halt all such development and call for the Legislature to restore our rights to the courtroom.
Rick Morris, Salt Lake City