The recent wave of statements regarding President-elect Donald Trump’s immigration plans has raised significant concerns. Specifically, Utah Gov. Spencer Cox’s announcement on Nov. 26 has sparked a debate about the true beneficiaries of the new immigration policies.
Gov. Cox stated that he aligns with the new administration and, in collaboration with the Utah Department of Public Safety and the Utah Department of Corrections, plans to help the Trump administration to deport illegal immigrants who are criminals within the state’s justice system.
Gov. Cox outlined five factors that will be considered when detaining illegal immigrants. These factors include the potential for deportation, involvement in murder, drug trafficking and other criminal activities that threaten the security of Utah. However, this raises a critical question: Who guarantees that there will be no arbitrary deportations that could result in the separation and destruction of entire families?
I work with an immigration lawyer at Eisenberg Lowrance Lundell Lofgren, and I have received numerous calls from people who are deeply afraid of what might happen after Jan. 20, when Trump assumes the presidency. Many fear being separated from their families, which is heartbreaking. While I believe the southern border does need to be controlled and order should be reestablished, it is essential to have a clear action plan. Making statements that incite popular terror, as is currently happening, is not the solution.
Even as a permanent resident, I understand the fear many people have. My parents, sisters and I fled the dictatorial regime in Venezuela seven years ago. While I became a permanent resident in 2022, they only have Temporary Protected Status (TPS). They fear losing this status, which would leave them without any legal opportunity to stay in the United States. Like many others, they came here with the desire to succeed and not to be a burden on the government or taxpayers. On the contrary, they are taxpayers themselves.
Gov. Cox’s position seems to be a strategic move to maintain popular approval in Utah and gain favor with Donald Trump, despite his past criticisms of the former president. This political maneuvering creates anxiety and fear within the immigrant community, who are simply seeking a better life.
Many individuals do not have the opportunity to legalize their status, but they are crucial to the development of Utah and the country. They were misled by the Biden administration’s Parole in Place program, which was dissolved shortly after Trump was elected.
I believe Utah is one of the best states to live in. It’s known for its receptiveness to foreigners, and the state’s development heavily relies on foreign labor to perform tasks that many Americans don’t want to do. It is vital for the state’s and the country’s development that everyone is recognized and respected.
While I agree with combating organized crime that destroys families, there must be a clear distinction between who is deported and who is not. Policies should not become an unfair and indiscriminate hunt for people who only want a chance at a better life in this country.
The real beneficiaries of the new immigration policies are not clear. While the Trump administration and Gov. Cox may gain political leverage, the immigrant community faces significant risks. The fear and uncertainty among immigrants highlight the need for a balanced and humane approach to immigration policy. It is crucial to ensure that policies do not lead to arbitrary deportations and the destruction of families, but rather focus on maintaining security while respecting the contributions of all residents.
(Gabrielle Pacheco) Gabrielle Pacheco is a political science student at Salt Lake Community College.
Gabrielle Pacheco is a political science student at Salt Lake Community College. She works for a law firm in South Jordan.
The Salt Lake Tribune is committed to creating a space where Utahns can share ideas, perspectives and solutions that move our state forward. We rely on your insight to do this. Find out how to share your opinion here, and email us at voices@sltrib.com.
