facebook-pixel

‘Trib Talk’: Vernal detective’s focus on sex-for-cash cases highlights the fine line between investigation and entrapment

(Illustration by Christopher Cherrington | The Salt Lake Tribune) Text messages exchanged by Vernal Police Detective Shaun Smith, posing as a woman, and men, according to records of Smith's investigations into sex solicitation. Smith frequently posed online as a woman who had a day job, but was willing to trade sex for money to pay bills.

(Illustration by Christopher Cherrington | The Salt Lake Tribune) Text messages exchanged by Vernal Police Detective Shaun Smith, posing as a woman, and men, according to records of Smith's investigations into sex solicitation. Smith frequently posed online as a woman who had a day job, but was willing to trade sex for money to pay bills.

The Vernal Police Department has made a priority of investigating sex solicitation cases, typically involving adult men looking to pay for casual sex with adult women. And the department’s approach relies on an undercover detective engaging in sometimes lengthy online conversations with alleged perpetrators.

But critics say Vernal’s investigative tactics may be stepping into the realm of entrapment, and prompting men to commit a crime when they otherwise would not. Those critics say that for the accused, pleading guilty and paying a fine may be easier, and less public, than challenging the grounds of their arrest.

On this week’s episode of “Trib Talk," Tribune reporter Jessica Miller and defense attorney Susanne Gustin join Benjamin Wood to discuss the makings of an entrapment claim, and why some question whether the Vernal Police Department takes solicitation stings too far.

"Trib Talk is produced by Sara Weber with additional editing by Dan Harrie. Comments and feedback can be sent to tribtalk@sltrib.com, or to @bjaminwood or @tribtalk on Twitter.

Click here to listen now. Listeners can also subscribe to “Trib Talk” for free on SoundCloud, iTunes and Apple Podcasts, Google Play, Stitcher and other major podcast platforms.