Former N.Y. FBI agent pleads not guilty in Utah case
A former FBI agent and a military contractor snared in a government fraud investigation each pleaded not guilty Tuesday to conspiracy, wire fraud and obstruction of justice charges during a brief hearing in U.S. District Court.
Prosecutors allege greed drove Robert G. Lustyik Jr., who worked as a counterintelligence specialist for the FBI in New York, to attempt to derail the case against Michael Taylor of Boston. In exchange for his help, Taylor allegedly promised to include Lustyik in lucrative business deals that involved gold, oil and alternative energy deals in the Middle East and Africa.
Prosecutors allege Taylor, 51, of Boston, and president of American International Security Corporation, conspired with two other men to defraud the U.S. military of millions after landing a contract to provide security and training to Afghan commandos.
Taylor has been detained in the Davis County Jail since his arrest and indictment in that case. Lustyik, 50, remains free. He was suspended and then retired from the FBI in September.
Boston attorney Raymond Mansolillo, who is representing Lustyik, vowed Tuesday after the brief court hearing that his client would present a "wonderful defense."
"We feel confident we're going to be exonerated," Mansolillo said.
Mansolillo also said he would not try to get the case moved to New York, where Lustyik lives, because he's been so "well received" by the court in Utah.
"We're fine with fighting the charges here," Mansolillo said, adding, "what better place to fight a charge of government abuse than Utah?"
However, prosecutors want Mansolillo disqualified from representing Lustyik, claiming he has a conflict of interest because of ties to Taylor and one other individual in the tangled cases.
In a hearing earlier this month, Mansolillo said prosecutors were using out-of-context snippets of emails exchanged between Lustyik and Taylor to build an "almost novel-like" case. As Taylor dangled business payoffs in the millions, Lustyik promised to "sway this your way" and "to blow the doors off this thing," according to court documents filed by prosecutors.
The two met in 2009, according to court documents, and developed a business relationship just as Utah investigators began a criminal investigation that included Taylor, whom they allege used inside information to land a military contract that eventually netted $54 million. Prosecutors say about half that sum was ill-gotten.
Taylor allegedly sought Lustyik's help after learning about the investigation. Lustyik first sought to block the investigation by enlisting Taylor as a confidential source and then as a cooperative witness in the case, a status that offered some immunity. He also enlisted numerous current and former FBI agents as character witnesses for Taylor, who had worked on other government investigations in the past.