Mendenhall's email to BYU players sheds light on why Doman was replaced by Anae

This is an archived article that was published on sltrib.com in 2013, and information in the article may be outdated. It is provided only for personal research purposes and may not be reprinted.

Long after news broke Friday morning that BYU coach Bronco Mendenhall was replacing offensive coordinator Brandon Doman with former OC Robert Anae — when most folks were wrapping up their work days — the school finally made the announcement official, saying in a lengthy (for them) news release that Anae "has been hired as the program's offensive coordinator." In case you haven't seen it, you can read the full release below, or by going to byucougars.com. Interestingly, the release makes mention of Doman only once — near the end — and doesn't spell out why the former BYU quarterback was released after just two years in the position. "One of Anae's first duties will be to work with Mendenhall to make coaching evaluations and any related offensive staff position assignments," it says. The most-asked question now becomes: Will Doman accept his demotion and stay on as quarterbacks coach, or leave? Most of the day, some good sources were telling me that Doman was leaning toward staying. Tonight, though, I am hearing that it is 50-50. A couple hours before BYU made the official announcement, Mendenhall sent an email to his players which sheds some light on why he made the change. I have obtained a copy of that email. Here it is: First, congratulations on an outstanding win in the Poinsettia Bowl. Your preparation for the game made the difference and it was the right way to end the season for our seniors. I hope you have all have had a good holiday break and are anxious to begin classes Monday and to start working to prepare for the 2013 season. There is a team meeting on Monday at 2:10 p.m. that you should plan on attending.Some changes in our coaching staff will be officially announced shortly and I felt you deserved to hear them directly from me before they were released publicly. After much consideration, I have made the decision to release Coach Brandon Doman from his responsibilities as offensive coordinator. I am very appreciative of his hard work, loyalty and enthusiasm for BYU. It was clear, however, that a change in leadership was needed for us to truly achieve what we are capable of as a team.Today were are announcing that Coach Robert Anae is returning to take over the offensive coordinator responsibilities. Many of you already know Coach Anae. For those who don't, he has spent the last two seasons at the University of Arizona in Tucson where he coaches the offensive line and serves as running game coordinator. Those who have played for Coach Anae in the past know that he is passionate about BYU and he'll do his very best to help each of our players reach their potential. We are fortunate to have Coach Anae back in the BYU family and are confident that our offense will regain the national prominence that it deserves. During the six seasons that Coach Anae was here, our offense was ranked in the Top 25 nationally five times. We also ranked in various Top 25 offensive statistical categories 28 times. Our offense was ranked as one of the top 6 passing offenses three of the six years he served as coordinator. At Arizona during the past two years, Coach Anae helped lead offenses that were ranked 16th in 2011 and 7th this season.I ask you to trust that the decisions that I have made—and will be making—are for the improvement of the program and will be done to provide you with the best opportunity to reach your personal goals while you are at BYU.Most of our coaching staff, including myself, will be attending the national coaches convention next week and will not be in the office Monday through Wednesday. I'll be happy to answer any questions you might have once I return on Thursday.With honor,Coach Mendenhall Here's the release from BYU:PROVO, Utah (Jan. 4, 2013) — BYU head football coach Bronco Mendenhall today announced Robert Anae has been hired as the program's offensive coordinator. "I am excited to announce Robert Anae as BYU's offensive coordinator," Mendenhall said. "During his career Robert has been involved with some of the best offensive schemes in college football, and he has a proven record of coaching elite-level offensive production. He is also a man of great intelligence, personal integrity, complete honesty and total loyalty. Robert is the ideal person to oversee our offense, and I'm thrilled he will be returning to BYU."Anae returns to his alma mater where he previously served as offensive coordinator and inside receivers coach on Mendenhall's staff from 2005-2010 before leaving to become the run game coordinator and offensive line coach at the University of Arizona. "I'd like to thank Greg Burns, Rich Rodriguez and the Arizona staff and players for an outstanding year in 2012. It was my privilege to be part of the Arizona program the past two years and to have coached the players I worked with in Tucson," Anae said. "I'd like to thank Tom Holmoe, Bronco Mendenhall and the BYU administration for the opportunity to return to BYU. My family and I look forward to an outstanding experience in a very familiar place." Anae spent the last two years at Arizona under Mike Stoops and Rodriguez, serving as offensive line coach both seasons and run game coordinator under Stoops. Arizona's offense ranked in the top 16 both years and was in the top 25 in passing both seasons as well. Arizona produced the No. 3 passer nationally with Nick Foles averaging 360.8 passing yards per game in 2011 before being drafted in the third round of the NFL draft by the Philadelphia Eagles. Anae's offensive line blocked for the nation's leading rusher in 2012, with Ka'Deem Carey picking up 1,929 yards and 23 touchdowns on 303 carries. Arizona ranked No. 7 in total offense this past season at 526.2 yards per game to help the Wildcats to an 8-5 record that included victories over nationally ranked Oklahoma State (59-38) and USC (39-36). The Wildcats scored 38.2 points per game to rank No. 16 nationally, including a 49-point output to defeat Nevada in the 2012 New Mexico Bowl. The point total was just three points off the New Mexico Bowl record of 52 points set by BYU in 2010 with Anae directing the Cougar offense. During Anae's first tenure as offensive coordinator at BYU, the Cougar offense was extremely successful, earning top-25 NCAA statistical rankings in 10 different offensive categories a total of 35 times, including 15 top-10 ratings. BYU ranked in the top 25 in third-down efficiency each of Anae's six seasons, including a No. 1 ranking in 2009 and No. 2 ratings in 2008 and 2006. The Cougars were in the top-6 in passing offense three times (2005, 2006, 2008) in his six seasons overseeing the BYU attack.BYU's offensive production under Anae helped produced the school's top two rushers of all time (Harvey Unga: 3,455 yards; and Curtis Brown: 3,221 yards), the program's top wide receiver in receiving yards, catches and touchdowns (Austin Collie: 3,255 yards and 30 touchdowns on 215 catches), BYU's highest achieving tight end in both receiving yards and catches (Dennis Pitta: 2,901 yards on 221 receptions) and the Cougars' winningest all-time quarterback (Max Hall: 32 victories as a starter). Hall and John Beck, who also played quarterback during Anae's tenure, both went on to the NFL with Beck earning All-America accolades at BYU. Pitta, meanwhile, not only set the BYU record for receiving yards by a tight end but also is No. 1 in that category in NCAA history. As BYU's inside receivers coach from 2005-2010, Anae helped Pitta, Jonny Harline and Andrew George earn a combined six All-Mountain West Conference tight end honors, including five first-team awards. BYU tight ends also achieved national accolades under Anae's tutelage as Harline received first-team All-America honors in 2006 and Dennis Pitta was named an NCAA Consensus All-American in 2009.Anae has been part of many of BYU's most successful teams as both a player and a coach. As BYU's offensive coordinator, the Cougars earned bowl invitations each season while winning two outright MWC championships and achieving an overall record of 56-21 (.727). He was an offensive lineman on BYU's National Championship team in 1984 and part of four bowl teams from 1981-84 while earning second-team All-Western Athletic Conference honors. BYU achieved a 43-7 record during Anae's playing days under Hall of Fame coach LaVell Edwards. He played in the Hula bowl in 1985 and was drafted by the New Jersey Generals of the USFL.A three-time Frank Broyles Award nominee for Assistant Coach of the Year (nominated at Texas Tech, BYU and Arizona), Anae is a 24-year coaching veteran at seven different schools. Anae's first stint as offensive coordinator at BYU came following five seasons coaching with Mike Leach at Texas Tech from 2000-2004. As offensive line coach for the Red Raiders, Anae helped put together some of the most prolific offenses in the NCAA. The Texas Tech offense ranked No. 1 in the nation in passing three out of Anae's five years and in the top 11 the remaining two. The Red Raiders also ranked in the top six in total offense three times, including 582.8 yards per game to lead the nation in 2003—the fifth-best mark in NCAA history.Anae began his coaching career as a graduate assistant working with the offensive line at Hawaii under Dick Tomey in 1986-87. He then was a grad assistant for a pair of years at BYU in 1990 and 1991 before coaching the offensive line at Ricks College in Idaho from 1992-95. He coached the offensive front for a year at Boise State in 1996 before moving to UNLV for a pair of seasons, the final as running game coordinator along with his line duties in 1998.Anae and his wife, Liane, have two sons, Famika and Max, and a daughter, Penny, who just got married on Dec. 29. His son Famika played on the offensive line at BYU before ending his career during the 2012 season due to injuries. Anae's father, Famika, and brothers Brad and Matt, also played football for BYU.He was born in California in 1958 and raised in Lai'e on Hawaii's north shore. He served as a missionary for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Tulsa, Okla., from 1978-80. He graduated from BYU in 1986, obtained a master's degree in sociology from BYU in 1990 and earned his doctorate in sociology from Brigham Young in 1999 while serving as an assistant director in the BYU student-athlete center and NCAA Life Skills director. Anae takes the vacant spot on Mendenhall's staff created when longtime assistant Lance Reynolds announced after BYU's Poinsettia Bowl victory that he is stepping away from coaching after a three-decade career at BYU. Anae assumes the offensive coordinator duties held the past two seasons by Brandon Doman. One of Anae's first duties will be to work with Mendenhall to make coaching evaluations and any related offensive staff position assignments. "I look forward to working with the young men on our team to represent the BYU brand of football that has characterized our program for decades," Anae said. "I look forward to developing the players on the offensive side of the football at a high level both on and off the field."